The game Gilbert plays with that history is refreshing in The Journal of the Main Street Lodge, Vol.2

The Journal of the Main Street Secret Lodge, Vol. 2

Stephen Gilbert, 289 pgs, Fourth Dimension, $19.95

Steven Gilbert’s second volume to this passionately local series brings the Victorian frontier narrative to Newmarket, Ontario, in a big way. The bulk of this volume tells of “The Incident at Black Willow Island,” where Captain Woodrow F. Gilbert faces down a Zodiac Killer-inspired crime syndicate as it sets up camp in the otherwise defenseless rural town. Gilbert’s narrative hits all beats expected in this kind of story — a stand-up, though conflicted, aging hero; multiple feats of amplifying danger; a sombre, justice-based resolution. It is the presentation, though, that sets the Main Street Secret Lodge apart from its contemporaries.

Gilbert sheds light on a geographic and cultural locale that sees very little attention in contemporary Canadian literature — the string of commuter-towns running north from Toronto once had histories and residents entirely removed from that city, and the clever game Gilbert plays with that history is a refreshing one. His stunning cross hatched illustrations stand out for their ability to engage in playful exaggeration in some instances, and bona fide sublime landscape elsewhere, representing a kind of middle ground between Daniel Clowes and Chester Brown. Thus, Gilbert’s visual style tells more of a story than his narrative ever seeks to. He captures a location and its dramatic moment in time without losing his sense of humour. A must-read.

Welcome to Broken Pencil, the magazine of zines, comics, DIY and the radical press since 1995.

Enjoy four free reads on us. If you like the work we do, please support us by subscribing!  Subscriptions are as cheap as $2 a month.